Sirens Submission Stats



So that’s the latest installment of the Magical Menageries anthology series put to bed. Okay, okay, I exaggerate slightly. I’m not quite done my end of things, but it’s close. Submissions have been solicited and read. Decisions, difficult decisions, have been made, contracts signed and edits have been sent to all the contributors.

At this point I’ve done a fair number of anthologies and each one comes with its own unique challenges. The biggest challenge with Sirens was that I had an embarrassment of riches. So many amazing stories to chose from. I’m not even kidding.

I received 199 submissions in total. I shortlisted 48 of them. That’s crazy! I’ve never had a shortlist that big before — nearly a quarter of my submissions. And what’s more, usually as an anthology develops it becomes apparent (with some few tricky exceptions) which stories from the shortlist you’re going to keep and which you’ll be passing on simply because they aren’t compatible with the others. That was not the case with this anthology. I wanted to accept every story from the shortlist.

In the end, I whittled those 199 submissions down into a table of contents of sixteen diverse stories that are going to blow you away.

Anthologies kind of take on a personality of their own as I work on them. Obviously they are strongly influenced by my choices, preferences and the theme, but they also have an energy of their own that helps determine the shape the book takes but in this case I had several completely different directions I could have gone in.

I’d been aiming for an equal number of ‘sea’ sirens as ‘sky’ sirens but that’s not how it turned out. Sometimes the lines between sea and sky are blurry, but I would say I’ve got ten sea stories, five sky stories and one space story, which reflects the general proportion of sea to sky submissions I received. The breakdown of those looks something like this:

Sea: 103
Sky: 35
Both: 13
Uncertain or Other: 48

Submissions came from all over the world including Australia, The Netherlands, Italy, Canada, Scotland, England, Sweden, Finland, South Africa, the Isle of Man and the United States of America.

Three of the submissions were duplicate submissions—where someone sent me the exact same story twice—and nine of them didn’t have an identifiable siren. Oops.

Four of the submissions were resubmissions where someone sent me something, received a revise and resubmit letter from me and took me up on that offer. I use a lot of labels in my email to keep things sorted and by the time contracts were being sent out one story had all the following labels on it:


We’ll have an actual table of contents and cover reveal coming up in a couple weeks (I’ve seen the cover, it’s awesome!) but I wanted to give you a bit of a peek into my slush for this anthology. It was an adventure, but the resulting book is something I am incredibly proud of. I can’t wait to share it with you!

This blog was originally posted at

Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...

2 thoughts on “Sirens Submission Stats”

  1. Thrilled, thrilled to be in this anthology – sounds like that was a lot of serious competition! Great to see someone from the Isle of Man in the list. I wonder who that is as that’s where I’m originally from…

Leave a Reply to Simon Kewin Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.